Richard Cottingham — The Torso Killer
Richard Francis Cottingham is an American serial killer who committed ten murders in New York State between 1972 and 1980, plus a further ten murders in New Jersey between 1965 and 1980. He was nicknamed by media as the Torso Killer and the Times Square Ripper, since some of the murders he was convicted of included acts of mutilation and dismemberment.
Featured Coverage
Case overview
Richard Cottingham, a computer operator at Blue Cross Blue Shield in New York City, was arrested May 22, 1980, at a motor inn in Hasbrouck Heights, New Jersey, after a woman who had been bound and tortured escaped and alerted police. Investigators connected him to the murders of young women in New Jersey and New York going back to the late 1960s, including two 1979 killings at a Times Square hotel in Manhattan in which victims' heads and hands had been removed — earning him the tabloid name "The Torso Killer."
Cottingham, born in 1946 in the Bronx and raised in New Jersey, maintained an outward profile of a middle-class family man: married, three children, stable employment. Over more than a decade he abducted women — primarily sex workers and young women encountered in bars — in New Jersey and New York, killing them generally in motel rooms. Many crimes went unconnected for years due to jurisdictional separation and the absence of centralized forensic databases.
[Beginning in 2010, Cottingham entered a pattern of confessing to additional unsolved murders](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/richard-cottingham-torso-killer-prison-interview-rcna18613), at times in exchange for details investigators provided him about unresolved cases. By the mid-2020s he had been formally connected to at least 11 confirmed murders across New Jersey and New York. Investigators from multiple counties have continued to question him about additional cold cases.
[Cottingham has been continuously incarcerated in New Jersey since his 1980 arrest. He received multiple convictions in separate state and county proceedings spanning decades.](https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/25/nyregion/the-region-173-year-sentence-in-jersey-murder.html)
New Jersey Convictions
[Cottingham was convicted in 1981 in Bergen County of five counts of murder and sentenced to multiple life terms.](https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/25/nyregion/the-region-173-year-sentence-in-jersey-murder.html) Subsequent New Jersey proceedings over following decades added additional murder convictions.
New York Conviction
[New York prosecutors charged Cottingham in the 1979 Times Square hotel murders. He pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder in New York in 1984 and received additional consecutive sentences.](https://www.nytimes.com/1984/07/10/nyregion/the-city-killer-of-2-is-guilty-of-3-more-slayings.html)
Additional Confessions & Late-Career Prosecutions
[Beginning in 2010, Cottingham confessed to additional cold case murders.](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/richard-cottingham-torso-killer-prison-interview-rcna18613) In 2020, Bergen County charged him with the 1969 murder of teenager Nancy Vogel; he pleaded guilty. In December 2022, Cottingham pleaded guilty to the 1968 Nassau County, New York, murder of Diane Cusick.
Current Status
Cottingham is incarcerated at South Woods State Prison in Bridgeton, New Jersey, serving sentences amounting to life without meaningful parole eligibility. He has been formally convicted of at least 13 murders across New Jersey and New York, and investigators continue to evaluate his claims regarding additional unsolved cases.
September 1, 2022
Convicted of 1969 Murder of Diane Cusick in New York
Cottingham was convicted in New York of the 1969 murder of Diane Cusick, a 23-year-old dance teacher — one of the oldest cold cases ever successfully prosecuted in New York state.
Source →August 26, 2022
Lorraine McGraw 1970 Murder Officially Corroborated by Rockland County
Rockland County, New York officials officially corroborated Cottingham's confession to the 1970 murder of 26-year-old Lorraine McGraw, whose body was found at a lover's lane in Nyack. The corroboration was reached through a non-prosecution agreement.
Source →April 27, 2021
Cottingham Pleads Guilty to 1974 Teen Double Murder
Richard Cottingham, then 74, pleaded guilty in New Jersey to the August 1974 murders of Mary Ann Pryor and Lorraine Kelly. As part of a plea agreement he received two additional concurrent life sentences, officially closing a cold case after 47 years.
Source →May 1, 2015
Convicted of Additional Cold Case Murders Under Plea Agreement
Under non-prosecution agreements, Cottingham confessed to additional cold-case murders, bringing his total confirmed victims to over a dozen and providing closure to families.
Source →June 19, 2014
Cottingham Confesses to 1969 Murder of Irene Blase
During an interview with Bergen County detectives, Richard Cottingham confessed to the 1969 murder of 18-year-old Irene Blase. The confession was part of a non-prosecution agreement and remained confidential for five years before being made public.
Source →May 1, 2010
Additional Confessions Begin
Cottingham began confessing to additional murders, eventually admitting to 16 total murders.
Source →January 1, 2009
Cottingham Claims He Committed 80 Perfect Murders from Prison
From prison, Cottingham told investigators he believed he had committed at least 80 murders of women across the U.S. that were never detected by police.
Source →June 1, 1984
Convicted of Four Additional Murders in New York
Cottingham was convicted of second-degree murder for four New York victims, adding further life sentences to his prior New Jersey convictions.
Source →May 1, 1981
Convicted of Five Murders in New Jersey
Cottingham was convicted of five counts of murder in Bergen County, NJ, and sentenced to multiple life terms — the first of several convictions across two states.
Source →May 22, 1980
Cottingham Arrested
Cottingham was caught in Hasbrouck Heights, NJ after a victim escaped. Found with a torture kit and victims' possessions.
Source →December 2, 1979
Two Headless Torsos Found at Times Square Hotel
The decapitated, de-handed bodies of two women were discovered at a Times Square hotel, earning Cottingham the nickname The Torso Killer.
Source →December 16, 1977
Maryann Carr Found Murdered in Little Ferry, NJ
Maryann Carr, a 26-year-old nurse, was found beaten and suffocated in a parking lot in Little Ferry, NJ — one of Cottingham's confirmed New Jersey victims.
Source →August 9, 1974
Teens Mary Ann Pryor and Lorraine Kelly Kidnapped
17-year-old Mary Ann Pryor and 16-year-old Lorraine Kelly left their North Bergen homes for a trip to a mall on August 9, 1974. Cottingham kidnapped, raped, and held both girls captive before drowning them in a motel bathtub. Their bodies were discovered August 14.
Source →December 27, 1973
Maria Emerita Rosado Nieves Found Strangled in Wantagh
18-year-old Maria Emerita Rosado Nieves, originally from Puerto Rico, was found dead in Wantagh, New York, strangled in a weeded area near a bus stop on Ocean Parkway. Her case was among several Long Island murders later linked to Cottingham.
Source →July 20, 1972
Laverne Moye Found Dead in Rockville Centre
23-year-old Laverne Moye of St. Albans, Queens, was discovered in a Rockville Centre waterway. She had been killed by strangulation. Her murder was one of several Long Island cold cases later attributed to Cottingham through confessions.
Source →May 10, 1972
Mary Beth Heinz Found Dead Near Rockville Centre Creek
21-year-old Mary Beth Heinz was discovered near a creek in Rockville Centre, New York, with cuts on her face and neck consistent with strangulation. She had vanished on May 5 while boarding a bus to a local dance. Her death remained unsolved for decades.
Source →July 14, 1969
Denise Falasca Strangled After Being Offered a Ride
15-year-old Denise Falasca was walking along a road in Emerson, New Jersey when Cottingham offered her a ride. She was strangled and her body found the following day. She had been reported missing on July 13.
Source →April 7, 1969
Irene Blase Abducted and Murdered in Hackensack
18-year-old Irene Blase of Bogota was abducted from a shopping area in Hackensack. Her body was pulled from the Saddle River in Saddle Brook the following day; she had been strangled with the chain from a crucifix she was wearing.
Source →July 17, 1968
Jacalyn Harp Strangled in Midland Park, New Jersey
13-year-old Jacalyn 'Jackie' Harp was strangled and murdered in Midland Park, New Jersey. Her body was recovered from a rural location. She was among Cottingham's teen victims during his early years of killing.
Source →February 15, 1968
Diane Cusick Found Dead Near Green Acres Mall
23-year-old dance teacher Diane Martin Cusick was found dead in the back seat of her car outside the Green Acres Mall in Valley Stream, New York. She had adhesive tape around her mouth and neck and had been manually strangled. The case remained unsolved for over 50 years.
Source →October 1, 1967
First Known NJ Murder Attributed to Cottingham
Circa 1967, Cottingham committed his first known murder in New Jersey, beginning a killing spree that would span 15 years across two states.
Source →January 24, 1967
Mary Ann Della Sala Disappears from Hackensack
Mary Ann Della Sala, a Shop-Rite employee, disappeared after her shift in Hackensack, New Jersey. Her body was later found in the Passaic River in Hawthorne; she had been strangled. This was among Cottingham's earliest documented New Jersey murders.
Source →September 24, 1965
Alys Eberhardt Murdered in Fair Lawn, New Jersey
18-year-old nursing student Alys Eberhardt was bludgeoned and stabbed to death in her Fair Lawn, NJ home. Cottingham used a fake police badge to gain entry. The case remained cold for decades until Cottingham's later confessions.
Source →Theresa Thornton
Theresa Thornton was a vibrant individual whose life was tragically cut short. She was known for her warm personality and dedication to her family and community. Her life ended in a New Jersey motel, marking her as one of the victims of Richard Cottingham, also known as the Torso Killer.
Helen Scialdone
Helen Scialdone was a cherished individual whose life was tragically cut short. Known for her warmth and kindness, she was a beloved member of her community in New Jersey. Her untimely death was part of a series of crimes committed by Richard Cottingham.
Maryann Carr
Maryann Carr was a vibrant individual whose life was tragically cut short in 1977. She is remembered for her warmth and kindness. Her untimely death was linked to Richard Cottingham, a notorious serial killer.
Richard Cottingham
Richard Francis Cottingham is an American serial killer who committed ten murders in New York State between 1972 and 1980, plus a further ten murders in New Jersey between 1965 and 1980. He was nicknamed by media as the Torso Killer and the Times Square Ripper, since some of the murders he was convicted of included acts of mutilation and dismemberment.
Irene Blase
Irene Blase was a vibrant individual whose life was tragically cut short. She was one of the many victims of Richard Cottingham, a notorious serial killer.
Victim Identification
The identification of several victims linked to Richard Cottingham, including their remains found in New Jersey and New York, establishes a clear pattern of his criminal activity and the nature of his offenses.
cbsnews.comConfession Statements
Cottingham's own confessions to law enforcement regarding his crimes provide direct evidence of his involvement in the murders, detailing his methods and motivations.
cbsnews.comForensic Evidence from Crime Scenes
Forensic analysis of the crime scenes, including DNA and other biological materials, helped link Cottingham to multiple murders and corroborated victim testimonies.
nbcnews.comSurveillance Footage
Surveillance footage from locations near the crime scenes provided visual evidence of Cottingham's presence in the area during the time of the murders, supporting the timeline of events.
imdb.comPolice Reports and Case Files
Documentary evidence from police reports and case files detail the investigation process, including witness statements and the collection of evidence, which is crucial for understanding the case's progression.
independent.co.uk
Appeal
1NJ Appellate Opinion — State v. Richard Cottingham
New Jersey Appellate Division opinion on multiple Cottingham cases, addressing evidence admissibility across trials for murders spanning decades.